Now that I’m starting to create short videos with my new LX3 the time has come to decide which video platform to host them on. There are literally hundreds of options but to me only three main contenders: YouTube, Vimeo & Flickr (let me know if you think I’ve missed anyone important). Having played with all three here’s my take on the pro’s and con’s and what I ended up choosing…

YouTube

The king of online video has come of age with support for widescreen and HD newly enabled. Over 13 hours of new footage is uploaded to YouTube every minute which clearly gives you some idea about the scale of its operations and the massive community it provides. The player is functional but not the most elegant out there.

Vimeo

Vimeo is more of a boutique platform which values quality over quantity and as such has a smaller community than it’s bigger brothers.  It’s always been an innovator and was one of the first to support HD streaming. Easily the most beautifully designed of the lot, some serious attention to detail has clearly gone into the interface.

Flickr

starwarsVstartrek

Late to the game, Flickr started off life a photo-only sharing site but has recently branched out into video also. It’s implementation is minimalist and elegant – current Flickr users should feel at home here. Its major disadvantage is that it doesn’t support HD yet and clips are limited to 90 seconds (a “long photo” as they call it!).

The result – I like Flickrs simplicity and YouTubes mass appeal but I’ll be using Vimeo to host my little creations. They have the right combination of solid technology, nice aesthetics and an internesting community. If Apple invented a video sharing site it’d be Vimeo.

Comments

  1. Shuo says:

    hmm…if you don’t mind…as for me,YB is too popular and even mussy,so I suppose if you put your creations there,they would be lowered.

    And VM is tooo slow for people like me.><

    Maybe FLr is the right call,since you’re a pro there and the video function is barely used by the mass.You may really be something down the road.^^

  2. David says:

    Hi Shuo, I agree with you about YouTube being messy and Vimeo being slow (most likely down to the poor network connection in/out China). Flickr also provides a great service but I’m still not convinced by the time limit they impose and lack of HD. Perhaps once I’ve got any videos worth sharing I’ll trial both.

Leave a Reply