Beijing China Culture History Hong Kong Japan Shanghai

Asia Book Review

Although I enjoy books, I’m a glacially slow reader and in a normal year might only finish two or three at most. Last year I, along with the rest of the world, found myself with considerably more free time and managed to get through a record number of tomes.

Instead of my usual diet of science fiction, I found myself drawn to historical and fictional accounts about the places I’ve enjoyed spending time in over the past decade, namely Hong Kong, Shanghai, Beijing, and latterly Japan; most of which are currently off-limits due to COVID travel restrictions.

I’ve been particularly interested in the pre/post-war periods of Shanghai and Hong Kong whose history is intertwined through colonialism and the refugees who migrated from one to the other during the conflicts which wracked China during the 20th century, the effects of which continue to reverberate today.

Below are some short reviews of what I’ve been reading.

Hong Kong

Gweilo

Memories Of A Hong Kong Childhood

by Martin Booth

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

A fascinating account of a British boy who grew up in colonial Hong Kong during the 1950s. He was often left to explore by himself and took full advantage to roam widely.

The book evokes a world rapidly disappearing from living memory and will be particularly nostalgic to anyone who has spent time in Hong Kong.

Diamond Hill

Memories of growing up in a Hong Kong squatter village

by Feng Chi-Shun

Rating: 3 out of 5.

In contrast to Martin Booth, Feng grew up in a Chinese refugee family living in a Kowloon-side squatter village.

While not quite as engaging as Booth’s depictions, Feng presents the early years of a life shaped by a now-extinct community and manages to overcome hardships to ultimately thrive.

Fragrant Harbor

by John Lanchester

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Chronicling the history of Hong Kong in the 20th century, the ambitious story is told through the voices of four different characters; a young journalist from England, a Chinese refugee, a Catholic nun, and a man from England who arrives with nothing and end up owning his own hotel.

Their stories all intertwine, and the choices they make ultimately raise questions about integrity, responsibility, and compromise.

The Honourable Schoolboy

by John le Carré

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Second in a trilogy of three classic spy novels, the book follows the Circus (aka the British Secret Service) as they attempt to rebuild their reputation and settle old scores after uncovering a Soviet double agent.

The energy and glamour of pre-handover Hong Kong and the turmoil-ridden landscapes of Cambodia, Laos and Vietnam are remarkably depicted. 

Shanghai

Last Boat Out of Shanghai

The Epic Story of the Chinese Who Fled Mao’s Revolution

by Helen Zia

Rating: 5 out of 5.

The book tells the dramatic real-life stories of four young people from different backgrounds caught up in the mass exodus of Shanghai in the wake of the Japanese occupation and China’s 1949 Communist revolution.

The moving accounts thought ultimately tragic, bear witness to the courage and grace of ordinary people and their ability to survive. 

Champions Day

The End of Old Shanghai

by James Carter

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Like with Last Boat Out of Shanghai, Champions Day follows the fortunes of those swept up in the fall of Shanghai to the Japanese in the 1940s through the lens of the Shanghai Race Club with all the class politics that surrounded it.

While there is a lot of horse racing detail I could have done without, it’s nevertheless a well written and engrossing read about the lives of both locals and Shanghailanders at the time.

City of Devils

The Two Men Who Ruled the Underworld of Old Shanghai

by Paul French

Rating: 3 out of 5.

City of Devils takes place in Shanghai on the cusp of World War II and follows the exploits of two displaced men who managed to run every kind of illegal activity known to man.

While I enjoyed French’s Midnight in Peking, I found the amount of trivia in here a bit hard going and an absence of anything to like in the characters.

Beijing

Long Peace Street

A Walk in Modern China

by Jonathan Chatwin

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Jonathan takes us on a 20-mile walk along Chang’an Jie (Long Peace Street) which cuts a straight line through the heart of Beijing.

It’s an interesting premise around which the modern history of China is retold and a good introduction to a city that can be very disorientating.

The Last Days of Old Beijing

Life in the Vanishing Backstreets of a City Transformed

by Michael Meyer

Rating: 4 out of 5.

As someone who lived in Beijing around the same time as Mayer (~2007) his deptiction of the destruction of the city’s oldest hutong neighbourhoods really hit home.

He tells the history of one of these courtyard homes from the unique vantage point of actually living, weaving historical vignettes with its then present day plight. The loss of communal life is heartbreaking.

China

Riding the Iron Rooster

By Train Through China

by Paul Theroux

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Theroux spent a year in 1987 travelling extensively throughout China by train. The China he explores is one just emerging from its era of isolation, and is in a mistrustful, albeit hopeful, period of testing the air let in from Deng Xiaoping’s open-door policies.

His cynical descriptions of the landscapes he encounters and the people he meets are both fascinating and occasionally hilarious. His sometimes condescending attitude has not aged well though.

Japan

Eat Sleep Sit

My Year at Japan’s Most Rigorous Zen Temple

by Kaoru Nonomura

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

At the age of thirty, Kaoru Nonomura left his regular life behind to undertake a year of ascetic training at Eihei-ji, one of the most rigorous Zen temples in Japan.

He describes his struggles in the face of beatings, hunger, exhaustion, fear, and loneliness, the comfort he draws from his friendships with the other trainees, and his quiet determination to give his life spiritual meaning. It’s a real eye-opener.

Walking in Circles

Finding Happiness in Lost Japan

by Todd Wassel

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Undertaken in 2005, before the advent of the English guidebook and smartphones, Todd manages to weave a very personal story with the history of the Shikoku Pilgrimage and how Japanese culture has shaped it.

Even as someone who thought they knew Shikoku pretty well, there is still a lot to learn here and it was a joy to follow Todd around the island while revisiting my own journals at the same time.

Kissa by Kissa

How to Walk Japan

by Craig Mod

Rating: 5 out of 5.

A lovingly handcrafted meditation on the culture of pizza toast (!) served up by a dying breed of Japanese cafés called kissaten which Craig samples as he walks 1,000+km along the ancient Nakasendō highway.

It couldn’t be much more apropos to my interests!

Up next on my reading list: The Years That Were Fat, Peking Story, East Sails West.

If you have any recommendations for books in a similar vein, please leave a comment below!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.